Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil

Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil

I’ve been working with Startups in the Indian Ecosystem for about 9 years now. Have been an entrepreneur / for the past 15 odd years, and over the past 9 years have met atleast 1000+ startups in the Indian Context, and interacted with quite a few globally.

About 18 months ago, we started an effort named In50hrs – a platform to bring together Ideasmiths, developers and designers together to pitch an idea, form teams and build prototypes of them, so that a) teams/Entrepreneurs find team members b) Learn how to build prototypes c) People get off their lazy butt and do something about that “brilliant idea” they’ve been sitting on. 18 Months, 10 events, Close to 400 participants. 180 odd Prototypes, and 25 startups later, I am coming to realize that Ideas Suck. They are evil and are absolutely the worst place to start a startup.

Pitchforks ready? Excellent. Now Let me explain.

The Starting Point

It has come to become the norm that the first step to build a startup is to think of an idea. Now imagine an entrepreneur, and he or she has about three to six months of money saved up in the bank and now wants to build a business and hopefully will succeed in building one that will have him or her land on her feet and atleast making the money that they were making while having the job. The chances of that happening when you start with an idea is very very very slim.

There is a reason why we force folks to talk about problems they are solving rather than jump right to solutions at In50hrs.

Now let’s go down the idea rabbit hole and see how far it goes:

You start with an idea and there is a chance that its a bit vague – most idea descriptions we get during prototyping events are. And over the past few months i’ve come to realize the ones that can turn into a business and the ones that cant. There are ideas that do get pitched saying :

“Here is a brand new way to manage tasks. it is based off the book or a theme like Getting things done, and we believe the current tools out there don’t do the job, and hence we have a new idea”.

By sheer proposition, there is nothing wrong with this, except that – apart for that spark of brightness, and the happiness of having thought of something out of nothing – the feeling of creative genius wraps over and then it takes over. The idea is converted into a product. The hunt for the elusive customer begins (sometimes to no avail and it starts to feel that perhaps only big foot will use this app – if only he can be found and a survey be done on him, or a beta app be released), pricing becomes a big issue if there is a payment – for free you get a few customers users, when you ask them how much they will pay for it, they circle around zero or a number that doesn’t make any sense – even to justify your cheapest cloud hosted service, One day you realize that people are starting to use the app for very strange uses and the audience is a bunch that you cannot relate to at all (Imagine if you are a logical programmer and a ton of creative artists start using your app), and the demands that come from them become something that is not very enjoyable. And then comes the last big question – the stake in the heart – is this scalable? You are a SaaS application and you found ten whacky artists (apologies to the artists) who were ready to pay, but you have absolutely no bloody clue how to find a thousand or ten thousand more of them to justify taking venture capital for this startup. By now, its probably month nine and you are way past the red line.

The realistic scenario is that the downturn happens much earlier. For a week you are overjoyed at the thought of the idea, then there is a slightly overwhelming nag that perhaps this idea is too big for you to execute, a sense of impatience comes by next, and for a little while followed that you are paranoid that someone is going to steal the idea – and timely enough you hit refresh in techcrunch and will come across an article on a startup doing the exact same thing – as if by psychic powers they stole the idea. Most people don’t recover from that emotional setback for a while, they get back eventually. Learn nothing and the cycle continues.

The Idea Emotional Wave. Most IdeaSmiths who start with an idea, not a problem, do head straight to crash and burn after the high.

Starting up as a Process, Not Shot in the dark

Building a business has to be a process. You can do it the creative way if you’d like (just follow the steps mentioned above a few more times) and don’t get me wrong, you will hit success in one of those chances. But the fact is that it is very unpredictable. Someone who can tell you when you will hit gold, is nothing short of a prophet. Side effect: When you yourself don’t know when the dawn will break, asking investors to come onboard, is mostly a futile exercise as well.

Starting from an “Idea” however has worked in large organizations, as mechanisms to do out of the box thinking and when the revenue from that exercise is not what will keep the lights on.

What Then, Mr. Doomsday?

In empathy for the lad or lady who has just quit her job and is looking to start something that will become a business in a set time frame, here is a proposal for a slightly structured way of going about it:. Step One : come up with an idea figure out who your audience is. If you are a human who has had any social communications with other human beings, you will realize that you are part of some circle, clique that you understand really really well. If you are young, and a student, you understand the student audience really well. If you are a professional with a few years of experience, you might have an audience within your profession, or area or expertise, or if you have taken an extra effort and built a blog or some expressive means, you have a follower base who you can relate to. That is as good as the best starting point to build a venture. Why? because you are one of them and there is nothing easier than to try to build something that you yourself would use.

This is the way businesses have been built in India. Some of the businesses classes have the luxury of extended audiences through their family networks etc, but i strongly believe everyone has an audience. Its just a matter of figuring out what that is.

The Lie

Now, I might have lied. Remember how I said Ideas are evil? Well not really. They are, if you let them loose and let them take you through the paralysis of the highs and the lows of creativity. Ideas are like rebellious teenagers and have momentum. If you can focus an idea, it is powerful. So what do you use?

You have to constrain an idea under the verticals of, an audience you know and can relate to and have access to, the value system that the audience has – lets say you have been an active community of the open source movement, the unsaid value system is that they believe software is and can be free – building something proprietary and trying to sell to them, might not work. Understand that. Note their pain points – never ever ask, but observe. I absolutely believe that Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle comes to play more often in this world than we imagine: If a subject that is under observation comes to know about it, they react to being observed – often in a way to mask what their real pain points are, and in expressing a digression. So observe where people emit pain points. If you are one with the entrepreneurial community, you’ll know how much people hate doing finances. There will be entire rants that developers will make about issues they have when trying to get something done and something standing in the way. Listen, observe and note them down, and see for patterns of it.


Step 1: Identify Audience

Step 2. Identify their value system

Step 3. Listen, Observe and note pain points

Once you have these three, ask yourself the final question – does the value system of this audience stop them from paying for a service and if they wouldn’t mind paying, what would their ability to pay be.

An example would be an iOS app developer. we know the typical app developer is paying 99$ per year for the license. Loses Shares 30% of all revenues with Apple. Marketing cost for most products are around 30-40%, so the developer has 30% left to pay for his time, infrastructure costs and take home something. If your pricing works out to be that you are demanding far more than that, its obviously not going to work. Understanding the business of your customers is pivotal. That’s where customer care really shows its head, to see if you really care.

So, step 4: Understanding the business economics of your customers to know viability.

Step 5: Would be to do a quick check to know if there is more than one customer that you can target. And a quick check on if there are more such clusters, would be an additional plus.

Lay all of this down on the board. Pin these as constraints and then think of ideas. It will be harder, but you will be far more focused and effective.

Some Examples:

1. I had the pleasure of Meeting Kunal Shah of Freecharge a few weeks back. The Concept is simple: You recharge your mobile / DTH via them, and they give you coupons worth the amount (in some cases more). While I have seen a few entrepreneurs try to replicate the model, five mins after I met Kunal it was very obvious that it was not a random idea he came up with. His previous stint with Paisaback – a cashback reward startup had given him enormous insight into what makes customers tick and in trying to solve the problem better for marketers, rather than giving cash – giving coupons, which are essentially a sales lead. There is no surprise as to why Freecharge is one of the highest transaction sites in the country (next to IRCTC ofcourse).

2. There are quite a few folks who are making an attempt to build something like twitter – hoping thats its vague at first, and without an exact “one liner” but evolves to become a fundamental tool over a period of time. While Twitter seems to have come out of thin air, the truth is that a) Jack Dorsey has had a history of building nifty products. b) The initial concept for twitter came about because of his worrying mother who always called to ask how he was doing and if he ate on time, and the tool was a way to keep her informed what he was up and about for the day. Listen to his talk at Stanford Technology ventures Programme.

A More closer to home example: BharatMatrimony – which is the biggest matrimonial site here in India with close to 40,000 new profiles being added every day, started off as a newsletter / site that targetted the NRI population while he was in the US. An experimental Matrimonial section spurred the interest that helped him make the pivot. But, there was already an audience that was built around the company – as early days as it was, that helped the entrepreneur figure out a better gold mine.

Sulekha – which in Sanskit means Good writing – in its previous avatar and the height of its glory days was THE destination for aspiring writers to come together, publish their short stories and essays, and there are plenty of folks who still have fond memories of the venture in that avatar. It started off as the founders’ interest in writing and build a “clan” around that. Audience building preceded an idea and a venture.

One of the biggest examples of a startup that built an audience, and catered to them would be 37Signals, but I believe they are rather over-quoted at this point. So I’ll share the example of this small, and amazing startup named Tenmiles. They are based in Chennai, and they have a portfolio of applications. The founder has a rather interesting philosophy of – a) knowing who he is building for before he builds anything. b) Making sure they will pay for the product – or atleast the very very near term. c) The first prototype that is made is made on a shoestring budget and tested for paying users – till the money is recovered, there is no further investments made. d) on crossing certain revenue milestones, the product is further developed. HelpdeskPilot, Doattend, are all products of such a process. I’ve heard of a very similar story with zoho and how its previous avatar Adventnet was built (completely bootstrapped as well)

Case of an Audience without Credibility:

Why is an audience so darn important? Shouldn’t a venture stand in the merit of its problem and how its being solved alone?. Good question and let me explain that with an example:

Being an accelerator, we do track interesting problems that need solutions and there potentially being a big opportunity. We don’t talk much about it, fearing that folks will consider this as RFPs and start building projects, but in any case, one of the opportunities that we are keeping an eye on, is we have been constantly hearing from a few large organizations on the CIO level that there is a need for dashboards – mobile dashboards, which can help their workforce be more efficient. Given the constraints of mobile, the key is to make minimalistic dashboards – so lets say I am one of the teams from the support side of things, i wouldn’t see anything related to finance, but I will see the number of tickets open, the average rate at which issues are being closed and the longest pending issue – with alerts for high risk showstoppers.

Interesting problem, and the solution to which cannot be that hard to build. it however requires that someone with credibility build a venture in this space – and someone with credibility might mean either a CIO or senior level management who was responsible on operation level of a mid-size t0 large enterprise, who probably can relate, associate and dig into his network to validate and sell this before the days clock turns over. It might be a few months before a young lad even cracks an appointment with the senior management to talk about the solution.

Bottom line: Sometimes, and more often than not, credibility with the audience matters to close that sale – especially in the case of B2B.

Circle back to the Goal:

Once this is done, start the second phase. Make a target of what is that revenue goal you wanted to achieve – say your salary, plus some additional bonus, plus some money to pay for taxes. Say it as a solid, round number. Work backwards and see how many customers you will have to get to make that money, what it costs to find each of that customers (this will be very very low because guess what, you are one of them, and they trust you and you know exactly where to find more of them).

The three biggests costs in a startup are – the cost of finding and convincing a customer, the cost of delivering the service and the cost of customer service. Most startups die before they figure out who their customers are, let alone figuring out what the cost of it will be in scale.

As George Costanza of Seinfeld, in the profound episode, revealed the truth: If what you are doing doesn’t work and seems to be spiraling down the twists and whirl of uncertainty, perhaps to get a predictable result, all you have to do is flip the problem on its head and do the opposite: find your audience and start there.

PS: The difference between the teams (at In50hrs) that become startups and the ones that fizzle out, strangely though seemed to be exactly that – one that is trying to solve a problem they understand, vs a shot in the dark.

Note: The views and opinions expressed are solely those of the author and does not necessarily reflect the views held by Inc42, its creators or employees. Inc42 is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by guest bloggers.

You have reached your limit of free stories
Become An Inc42 Plus Member

Become a Startup Insider in 2024 with Inc42 Plus. Join our exclusive community of 10,000+ founders, investors & operators and stay ahead in India’s startup & business economy.

Unlock 60% OFF
Cancel Anytime
Unlock 50% OFF
Cancel Anytime
Already A Member?
Discover Startups & Business Models

Unleash your potential by exploring unlimited articles, trackers, and playbooks. Identify the hottest startup deals, supercharge your innovation projects, and stay updated with expert curation.

Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil-Inc42 Media
How-To’s on Starting & Scaling Up

Empower yourself with comprehensive playbooks, expert analysis, and invaluable insights. Learn to validate ideas, acquire customers, secure funding, and navigate the journey to startup success.

Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil-Inc42 Media
Identify Trends & New Markets

Access 75+ in-depth reports on frontier industries. Gain exclusive market intelligence, understand market landscapes, and decode emerging trends to make informed decisions.

Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil-Inc42 Media
Track & Decode the Investment Landscape

Stay ahead with startup and funding trackers. Analyse investment strategies, profile successful investors, and keep track of upcoming funds, accelerators, and more.

Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil-Inc42 Media
Why Ideas are a Bad Place to Start a Startup – or – Why Ideas are Evil-Inc42 Media
You’re in Good company