Vijay Shekhar Sharma Calls Google Toll Collector; Paytm First Games Back On Google Play

On the day Paytm First Games made a comeback on Google Play Store, founder Vijay Shekhar Sharma called Google a toll collector. Speaking at Paytm’s Mini App Developer Conference on Thursday, he added that developers working with Paytm Mini App Store, won’t be charged any commission for in-app purchases on their apps. 

Earlier in the day, Paytm revealed in a blog that Paytm First Games will feature all upcoming IPL matches and soccer tournaments, where users can win upto INR 1 Lakh everyday. However, the financial services giant minced no words to explain the “dichotomy of Google Play’s policy and of Google’s Ads business.”

On whether real money gaming apps will be listed on the Paytm Mini App Store, Sharma said, “Google has vague policies so we can not confirm till we have more details and research on it.”

“We wish to make it clear that as per Indian laws, Fantasy sports are completely legal and allowed all over India, except in few states like Assam, Odisha, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. The arbitrary (and self-serving) policies of Google, and their arbitrary interpretation of these policies is a dangerous, and extra-judicial, enforcement of monopolistic powers, against the interest of developers and users,” Paytm said.

Troubles began for Paytm when Google On September 18 took down Paytm’s app from the Play Store for violating policies related to gambling payments. However, it was back on the same day.

While removing Paytm First Games and Paytm apps, Google in its policy update had said that the Play Store policy prohibits online casinos and other unregulated gambling apps that facilitate sports betting in India.

Earlier, Paytm in a blog post called its takedown and subsequent restoration from the Android app store ‘arm-twisting’ by the global search major.

Google, however, issued a statement clarifying that cashbacks and stickers do not violate its policies, but gambling platforms do. Essentially, the company took down Paytm from its platform on Friday because the platform was using its payments app to promote Paytm First Games, which has a daily fantasy sports aspect to it, hence violating Google’s policies.

Online Gambling Caught Between Skill, Chance & Regulation In India

Online gambling walks the thin line between skill, chance and strict regulations. A myriad of policy regulations and the onus of respective Indian states to take a stand on gambling has created a policy labyrinth. 

Supreme Court judgments since the 1960s have held that games such as poker and rummy have a dominant element of ‘skill’, which trumps the element of ‘chance’, hence ruling that both games are skill-based card games and as such, should be exempted from the anti-gambling regulations when played for stake. 

However, given that gambling is a state subject, different states have framed their laws, some of which have outrightly banned all real-money card games. These include Telangana and Odisha, where there’s a blanket ban on card games played for a stake. 

In states such as Sikkim and Nagaland, while the respective state governments have excluded the staking of money on games of skill from the ambit of gambling, the operators of online portals for such games are mandated to get licenses for conducting such games within state boundaries. 

Plus, there are games that may prima facie look like games of skills but their rules and features may not fit the legal definition, which also complicates the situation further.

Note: We at Inc42 take our ethics very seriously. More information about it can be found here.