Why Narayana Murthy Is Wrong About VC Funds Being A Ponzi Scheme

A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment scheme in which returns are paid to earlier investors using the capital of newer investors. Ponzi schemes typically collapse when there are not enough new investors to pay the returns promised to earlier investors. 

Venture capital, on the other hand, involves investing in early-stage companies with high growth potential. A startup needs to solve a user problem first and then the VC capital follows to accelerate growth.

Venture capitalists provide capital to these companies in exchange for an ownership stake, and they typically exit their investment through an initial public offering (IPO) or acquisition. Let me first start by admitting that “shareholder value at all costs” and “growth at all costs” mindsets are unhealthy for a fair economy, a just society, and long-term sustainability. 

Venture capital provides funding for innovative Indian startups that may not have access to traditional sources of financing like debt from banks. This funding can help these startups develop new technologies, products, and services that can contribute to economic growth and job creation. 

High-velocity startups will need to burn capital to sustain their growth prior to achieving profitability. Losing money is no one’s priority but we know the fact that startups focused on rapid growth do lose money. Few startups tend to lose money for a longer time horizon than others for multiple reasons. Each startup has its own journey of making money there is no standard template to apply. 

I believe there is nothing wrong if the startup is making losses as long as there is a path to profitability. There are enough and more examples of startups building growth before profitability. While there have been instances of fraudulent behaviour by individual venture capitalists, the industry as a whole is not a Ponzi scheme. 

VC Funding: The Answer To Innovation & Growth

Venture capital plays an important role in fostering innovation and economic growth by providing capital and expertise to help startups grow and succeed. Choosing not to be profitable in favour of growth is now a strategy as long as in the future large profits can be anticipated. The public-listed tech unicorns in the US with losses have been faring far better than their profitable counterparts. 

VC firms have provided funding and support to iconic companies such as Apple, Microsoft, Google, and Facebook, which have gone on to become some of the largest and most successful technology companies in the world. Other examples are Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn, which have transformed the way we connect and communicate with one another. Many VC-funded companies such as Uber, Airbnb, and WeWork, have transformed the way we travel, work, and live. VC funding can help to diversify the Indian economy by supporting startups in a variety of industries. This can help to reduce the country’s reliance on traditional industries and create new opportunities for economic growth. 

Venture capital is not just about providing funding to startups. It also involves mentoring and supporting these companies to help them grow and succeed. At 100X.VC we write the first cheque at the seed fund and then work with these companies with 100+ hours of mentoring to help them scale their business. Startups want to capture a significant share of the market they operate in. 

Hence growth capital helps them with a competitive advantage over other players in the market and helps them establish themselves as the dominant player in their space. VCs often focus on growth as a way to increase their valuation. Higher valuations can lead to larger investments, greater access to capital, and ultimately, more potential for a successful exit through an IPO or acquisition. 

VC firms typically provide not just financial capital, but also strategic guidance, industry expertise, and access to a network of contacts and resources that can help startups navigate the challenges of scaling their businesses. VC firms often take an active role in working with the startups they invest in, providing mentorship, advice, and support on everything from product development and marketing to fundraising and talent acquisition. 

While venture capital is about investing capital in promising startups the goal of a fund manager is about discovering disruptive ideas, providing support and guidance, and helping entrepreneurs realise their visions and achieve their goals. Ultimately venture capital model is designed for the monetisation of startup ideas.

Note: We at Inc42 take our ethics very seriously. More information about it can be found here.