Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit

Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit

SUMMARY

In his judgement, Justice AS Chandurkar observed that the units are violative of Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution

The ruling comes eight months after a two-judge Bombay bench gave a split verdict in a petition filed by Kamra and others challenging the setting up of the FCUs

The IT Amendment Rules, 2023 empower the union government to set up FCUs for identifying “fake, false, or misleading” content online related to the Centre

The Bombay High Court (HC) on Friday (September 20) struck down Centre’s proposed fact-checking unit (FCU) while hearing a plea filed by standup comedian Kunal Kamra.

The Information Technology Amendment Rules, 2023, notified last year, empower the union government to set up FCUs for identifying “fake, false, or misleading” content online with regards to the Centre. 

In his judgement, Justice AS Chandurkar observed that the units are violative of Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution, adding that the expression “fake or false or misleading” is “vague and overbroad” in the absence of any definition. 

“Having considered the matter extensively on the points of difference, I would conclude by opining that… Rule 3(1)(b)(v) of the Rules of 2021 as amended in 2023 is violative of the provisions of Article 14, Article 19(1)(a) and Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution… The said Rule as amended is ultra vires the Act (IT) of 2000,” said Justice Chandurkar.

He also noted that the “impugned rule” will result in a “chilling effect” on digital intermediaries.

The ruling comes eight months after a two-judge Bombay HC bench gave a split verdict on the petition filed by Kamra and others challenging the setting up of the FCUs. In their petition, the complainants claimed that the IT Rules amendments will put unreasonable restrictions on freedom of speech and expression.

They also claimed that the new mandates will lead to government-led censorship online and empower authorities to be the “prosecutor, the judge, and in that loose sense, the executioner” of what constitutes the ‘truth’ online.

In January, while Justice Patel struck down the rules saying they amounted to censorship, Justice Gokhale upheld the mandates noting that they did not have any “chilling effect” on free speech as argued. Eventually, the matter went to a third judge, Justice Chandurkar, who heard the matter and passed the ruling on September 20. 

Notably, the Supreme Court (SC), in March, stayed an official notification announcing the operational status of the Centre’s official FCU. The court observed that the union government could not move ahead on the plan of setting up the unit until the Bombay HC decides on the constitutionality of the matter.

Note: We at Inc42 take our ethics very seriously. More information about it can be found here.

You have reached your limit of free stories
Become An Inc42 Plus Member

Become a Startup Insider in 2024 with Inc42 Plus. Join our exclusive community of 10,000+ founders, investors & operators and stay ahead in India’s startup & business economy.

2 YEAR PLAN
₹19999
₹7999
₹333/Month
Unlock 60% OFF
Cancel Anytime
1 YEAR PLAN
₹9999
₹4999
₹416/Month
Unlock 50% OFF
Cancel Anytime
Already A Member?
Discover Startups & Business Models

Unleash your potential by exploring unlimited articles, trackers, and playbooks. Identify the hottest startup deals, supercharge your innovation projects, and stay updated with expert curation.

Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit-Inc42 Media
How-To’s on Starting & Scaling Up

Empower yourself with comprehensive playbooks, expert analysis, and invaluable insights. Learn to validate ideas, acquire customers, secure funding, and navigate the journey to startup success.

Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit-Inc42 Media
Identify Trends & New Markets

Access 75+ in-depth reports on frontier industries. Gain exclusive market intelligence, understand market landscapes, and decode emerging trends to make informed decisions.

Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit-Inc42 Media
Track & Decode the Investment Landscape

Stay ahead with startup and funding trackers. Analyse investment strategies, profile successful investors, and keep track of upcoming funds, accelerators, and more.

Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit-Inc42 Media
Bombay HC Strikes Down Centre’s Bid To Set Up Fact-Checking Unit-Inc42 Media
You’re in Good company